You Can Leave. But He Stays – TNBS NEWS — Original Short Stories & Fiction
Posted in

Part 4: You Can Leave. But He Stays

<span class="fs-story-title-part-prefix">Part 4:</span> You Can Leave. But He Stays

She leaned into me then, just for a second, her forehead against my shoulder. She hadn’t done that since she was fifteen. I felt her shaking.


“Don’t leave us here alone,” she whispered.

“I’m not going anywhere without you knowing exactly where I am,” I said. “I’ll be fifteen minutes away. I’ll keep my phone on. You lock this door and don’t open it for anyone but me. Not the maid. Not anyone.”

She nodded against my shoulder. Leo’s tiny hand had found her shirt and twisted it.

We didn’t sleep. We sat with the lamp on, listening to the trucks on Grand Avenue a few blocks over, watching Leo breathe. At 5:30 the sky started to turn gray behind the curtain. At 6:00 Gaby fed Leo with a bottle we had bought at the gas station, her hands steadier when she was holding him. At 7:45 I kissed the top of her head and the top of his and left the motel with the spare key in my pocket and my old work jacket on, the one with Whitaker Auto stitched over the heart.


The diner on 7th and McDowell hadn’t changed in twenty years. Same cracked vinyl booths, same smell of grease and coffee that had been on the grill since 6 a.m. I was there at 8:40 and took a booth where I could see both doors. At 8:58 a man walked in who didn’t look like the broad-shouldered messenger from last night.

He was older than Derek, maybe forty, with a shaved head and a mechanic’s hands and a folder under his arm that had seen better days. He wore a clean but faded work shirt that said Miller Custom Builds on the back. He saw me and his face did something complicated, relief and shame at once.

“Mr. Whitaker?” He slid in across from me without waiting for an invite. He kept his hands on the folder. “I’m Carlos Reyes. I ran Derek’s crew for three years. Framing, drywall, the flip houses Brenda finds at auction.”

I studied him. His eyes were red like he hadn’t slept either.

“You sent the message.”

He nodded and pushed the folder across the table. “I didn’t know what else to do. They owe me and two other guys a hundred and eighty grand for the last three jobs. When I said I was going to file a lien, Brenda laughed. She said her brother Mason handles paperwork. That if I tried anything she’d make sure I never pulled a permit in this county again.”

He opened the folder. Inside were copies, not originals, but clear enough. A quitclaim deed. A durable power of attorney. A transfer of vehicle title for a gray Tacoma. All with Gaby’s signature in that loopy handwriting she learned from her mother, but the dates were wrong. They were all dated within four days of Leo’s birth, when Gaby told me she hadn’t left the house except for the pediatrician.

“She was on pain meds,” Carlos said quietly, looking down at the signatures. “Mason told me. He was proud of it. He said Derek kept her awake for two nights with the baby crying, then Mason came over at ten p.m. with the stack. He put little pink tabs where to sign. She signed the deed, the car, and a paper that lets Derek access her accounts. Mason notarized it himself. He’s not even a notary anymore. His license lapsed last year.”


My hands were shaking. I put them flat on the folder to hide it.

“There’s more,” Carlos said. He pulled out his phone and turned it sideways. A video, taken from a doorway, shaky. Brenda’s voice, sharp and clear: “You need to make her look unstable. If she begs, if she’s on the street with that baby, no judge will look twice. Get her out of the house. Tell her she has to earn her keep. Take pictures. Lots of pictures.”

Derek’s voice, laughing: “She’ll do whatever I say. She thinks I’ll call CPS.”

The waitress came over with coffee I hadn’t ordered. Carlos waited until she left.

“They kicked her out two months ago,” he said. “Told her she had to go. Then they told people at the shelter not to let her stay too long. Brenda donates there, you know. Small donations, but enough to get the manager to listen. And that photo your daughter got last night? That wasn’t from me. But I know who took it. Derek paid a kid twenty bucks to sit across from the shelter and take pictures every day for a week. For evidence, he said. To prove she’s an unfit mother.”

My throat was so tight I could barely swallow the coffee. So it was staged. The whole thing. Not just the papers. The begging. The plastic cup. My daughter standing in hundred-degree heat between cars because they told her it was the only way to feed her child, and then they photographed her doing it to use against her.


“They’re filing Monday,” Carlos said. “Emergency custody. They have a packet ready. Photos of her begging, bank statements showing zero balance, a letter from a doctor Brenda knows saying Gaby has postpartum depression and refused treatment. It’s all in there. They want the house and they want the kid so she can’t leave. Mason gets a cut of the house when they flip it.”

He pushed one last paper across. A draft petition for sole custody, with Derek Miller listed as petitioner, and a note in the margin in Brenda’s handwriting: File 8am Monday. Judge Harrell.

I stared at that name. I didn’t know a Judge Harrell, but I knew what Monday meant. Four days.

“Why are you helping us?” I asked.


Carlos’s jaw tightened. He looked out the window at the traffic on 7th.

“My sister had a baby at seventeen,” he said. “Her boyfriend did the same kind of thing. Took her money, told her she was crazy. If someone had shown me proof back then… I don’t know. I just can’t watch it again. And they owe my guys money. They think they can steal from everyone forever.”

I closed the folder. My hands had stopped shaking. Now they were steady in that way they get when you’ve decided to do something hard and you’re not going to flinch.

“Will you come with me to my lawyer?” I asked. “Will you show him this?”

Carlos nodded. “I’ll do more than that. I’ll go on record. But you need to move fast. Once they file, even if it’s lies, it takes months to fix.”

I paid for both coffees and left a ten on the table. Outside the diner the sun was already brutal. I called Frank Delaney from the parking lot. Frank had been my lawyer since I opened the second shop. He’d drawn up the townhouse papers himself. He answered on the second ring.

“George? It’s been a while.”

PART 5
STORY

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *